The Search for the Next Head of School of St. Thomas’s Day School

After 14 years at St. Thomas’s Day School, Gina Panza announced her decision to retire from her position as Head of School at the conclusion of the 2026-2027 academic year. Gina’s tenure at St. Thomas’s saw tremendous accomplishments and growth including cultivating and inspiring an exceptional faculty, strengthening the School’s financial position, fostering the collaborative partnership with the parish and guiding the purchase of the School’s campus to secure it’s long term future. Her work leaves a strong foundation for our future as we determine the School’s next educational leader.

St. Thomas’s Day School is partnering with Educators Collaborative to conduct a comprehensive, national search for the sixth Head of School. We are seeking an individual who embraces our identity, honors our commitment to excellence, and will lead the School with thoughtfulness and vision into its next chapter. This webpage will serve as a resource for current and past St. Thomas’s community members to stay informed on the search progress.

Community Updates

Questions about the search process and expressions of interest may be directed to:

Carole Everett
Partner, Educators Collaborative
ceverett@educatorscollaborative.com

We are grateful for the St. Thomas’s Day School community’s interest, participation, and support as we undertake this important search for the school’s next leader.

Frequently Asked Questions

After 14 years of dedicated leadership, Gina Panza has announced that she will retire at the conclusion of the 2026–2027 school year. We are deeply grateful for her many contributions to St. Thomas’s Day School and the strong foundation she has helped build.

The search for her successor provides an important opportunity to celebrate the school’s accomplishments, reflect on its mission and values, and consider the leadership that will best serve St. Thomas’s in the years ahead.

The Board of Trustees has the ultimate responsibility for appointing, supporting, and evaluating the Head of School.

The Board has established a Search Committee representing a range of perspectives within the school community to guide the search and recommend a candidate for the Board’s consideration. The Board will make the final appointment.

The Search Committee is entrusted with conducting a thoughtful, thorough, and confidential search that serves the best interests of St. Thomas’s Day School. Its members bring perspectives from across the school community and share a commitment to the school’s mission, values, and future. They are expected to approach their work with open minds, listen respectfully to differing viewpoints, disclose any potential conflicts of interest, and maintain strict confidentiality.

Working with the search consultant, the Committee reviews candidate materials, selects and interviews semifinalists, identifies finalists, and ultimately recommends a candidate to the Board of Trustees.

Committee members commit to attending all meetings, participating fully in discussions, and reaching decisions by consensus. The Committee seeks to present a unified recommendation that reflects its collective judgment rather than individual preferences.

Yes. St. Thomas’s Day School has engaged Carole Everett, a Partner at Educators Collaborative, to guide the search.

Founded in 1971, Educators Collaborative specializes in Head of School and senior leadership searches for independent schools.

Carole is a former Head of School and independent school administrator who served for 14 years as Executive Director of the New Jersey Association of Independent Schools. She brings extensive experience working with school leaders and Boards on governance, leadership searches, and
transitions.

She will work closely with the Search Committee throughout the process, including community engagement, candidate recruitment and evaluation, reference checking, and preparation for the leadership transition.

Carole may be reached at ceverett@educatorscollaborative.com.

Community participation is an essential part of the search process. Families, faculty, staff, trustees, alumni, and other members of the St. Thomas’s community were invited to complete a confidential survey about the school’s strengths, challenges, and priorities for its next Head.

Carole Everett also visited the school to meet with students, parents, faculty, staff, administrators, trustees, alumni, and other community members. These conversations, together with the survey results, will help shape the Leadership Profile for the next Head of School.

There will be another opportunity for community participation when finalists visit campus. Community members will be invited to meet the finalists and share their impressions through confidential feedback surveys.

The Information for Candidates/Leadership Profile introduces St. Thomas’s Day School to prospective candidates and describes the experience, leadership qualities, and personal characteristics most important in its next Head.

It is informed by the community survey, listening sessions, and discussions with the Search Committee. Once completed, it will be shared on the school’s webpage. Educators Collaborative will conduct a broad search, reaching out to qualified educational leaders through professional networks, referrals, and direct recruitment.

Candidates will be evaluated against the Leadership Profile, with particular attention to their educational philosophy, leadership experience, judgment, interpersonal skills, and ability to advance the school’s mission.

The process includes a careful review of professional credentials, interviews, reference checks, and other appropriate background research. The Search Committee will review the strongest candidates, conduct confidential semifinalist interviews, and invite a small number of finalists to campus.

Yes. Qualified members of the St. Thomas’s Day School community who are interested in the position are welcome to apply.

Internal and external candidates will follow the same search process and be evaluated according to the same criteria. Internal candidates are expected to maintain the confidentiality of their candidacy and refrain from campaigning or seeking support within the school community.

This approach ensures that every candidate receives fair and thoughtful consideration. It also allows the Search Committee to conduct its due diligence, evaluate each candidate in the context of the full applicant pool, and make a recommendation grounded in the school’s needs.

A consistent process protects the integrity of the search, strengthens the credibility of the eventual appointment, and treats all candidates with equity, care, and respect.

Gina Panza will continue to lead St. Thomas’s Day School throughout the 2026–2027 school year. She will provide institutional background and perspective to the search consultant and assist with planning and coordinating the process as appropriate. She will also have an opportunity to meet the finalists during their campus visits and provide feedback to the Search Committee.

The search began in fall 2026 and is expected to conclude in early 2027.
The major stages are:

â—Ź Fall 2026: Community survey, listening sessions, development of the Leadership Profile, and candidate recruitment.
â—Ź January 2027: Search Committee review of candidate materials and confidential semifinalist interviews.
â—Ź February 2027: Finalist campus visits, community feedback, Search Committee deliberations, and Board consideration.
â—Ź Early 2027: Announcement of the next Head of School, following a successful appointment process. Transition begins. EC supports the Head and Board throughout the first year of the new Heads service.
â—Ź July 1, 2027: New Head of School begins.

The schedule may be adjusted as necessary to ensure a thoughtful and thorough process.

Confidentiality is essential to attracting and protecting strong candidates, many of whom are currently serving in leadership positions at other schools.

During the initial stages, candidate identities and Search Committee deliberations will remain confidential. This allows candidates to explore the opportunity without jeopardizing their current professional responsibilities and permits the Committee to evaluate each person fairly.

Finalists will participate in campus visits involving members of the school community, who will also be asked to respect the confidentiality of the process.

While not every detail can be shared publicly, the school will provide updates at appropriate points throughout the search. There may be periods when relatively little news can be shared. This is a normal part of the process and does not mean that progress has slowed.

Finalists will spend approximately two days on campus, meeting with trustees, administrators, faculty, staff, parents, and students.

These visits provide candidates with a deeper understanding of St. Thomas’s Day School and give community members an opportunity to learn about the candidates’ experiences, leadership approaches, and educational values.

Participants will be invited to complete confidential feedback surveys. The Search Committee will carefully consider that feedback, together with interviews, references, and other information, before reaching a consensus recommendation.

The Board of Trustees will make the final appointment, which will be announced once the process has been completed.

The next Head of School is expected to begin on July 1, 2027.

Between the appointment announcement and that date, the Board, current Head, and school leadership will work to support a smooth and successful transition.

Educators Collaborative will also provide guidance during the transition to help the new Head.

We welcome recommendations from members of the St. Thomas’s Day School community. If you know an  educational leader who might be well suited to the position, please share the person’s name and contact information directly with Carole Everett. She will follow up directly and confidentially.

Carole may be reached at ceverett@educatorscollaborative.com.